Adam Smith, Friedrich Hayek and Karl Marx: The Distinction between Free Market, Mixed, and Command Economies
Adam Smith, Friedrich Hayek and Karl Marx: The Distinction between Free Market, Mixed, and Command Economies
Level: AS Levels, A Level, GCSE – Exam Boards: Edexcel, AQA, OCR, WJEC, IB, Eduqas – Economics Revision Notes
Who are Adam Smith, Friedrich Hayek, Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes?
Adam Smith
Adam Smith is considered the father of modern economics and is known for his work “The Wealth of Nations,” in which he describes the benefits of a free market economy. In a free market economy, supply and demand dictate the prices of goods and services, and there is minimal government intervention.
Friedrich Hayek
Friedrich Hayek was an Austrian economist who built on Smith’s ideas to advocate for a limited government role in a free market economy. He argued that too much government intervention can lead to inefficiency and that a market system is better at allocating resources.
Karl Marx
Karl Marx, on the other hand, advocated for a command economy in which the government owns and controls the means of production. According to Marx, this is necessary to eliminate the exploitation of the working class that he saw as inherent in a capitalist system.
John Maynard Keynes
John Maynard Keynes, a British economist from the early 20th century, is renowned for founding Keynesian economics. A key principle of Keynesian economics is the belief that governments should proactively influence economic trends, particularly by increasing spending to boost demand during recessions.
What is the difference between a Free Market, Mixed Economy and a Command Economy?
Free Market Economy
In a free market economy, individuals and businesses are free to make their own economic decisions, and the government plays a minimal role in regulating the economy. Prices are determined by supply and demand, and resources are allocated through the market mechanism of competition. The theory behind a free market economy is that it will ultimately lead to economic growth and prosperity for all.
Mixed Economy
A mixed economy combines elements of both capitalism and socialism, resulting in a balance of private and public ownership and control. It allows for a degree of government intervention and regulation, but also recognizes the benefits of a market-based system. A mixed economy aims to achieve a balance between economic growth, social welfare and stability
The role of government in a mixed economy: The government in a mixed economy plays a significant role in regulating the economy, providing public goods and services, and redistributing income to ensure a more equal distribution of wealth. It can also intervene to correct market failures and provide for the needs of disadvantaged groups.
Command Economy
In a command economy, the government has complete control over the means of production and makes all economic decisions. Resources are allocated based on government plan and command rather than market prices. The government also sets prices and production goals. The theory behind a command economy is that it will lead to greater equality and a more efficient use of resources.
Adam Smith’s theory of the Invisible Hand
Adam Smith argues that the pursuit of self-interest by individuals and businesses in a free market economy leads to an “invisible hand” that guides the economy to produce the greatest benefit for society as a whole.
Friedrich Hayek’s theory of Spontaneous Order
Friedrich Hayek, argued that the free market economy, if left to its own devices, will achieve a “spontaneous order” where individuals, guided by the invisible hand of the market, coordinate their actions without the need for central planning. He believed that government intervention can disrupt this spontaneous order and reduce economic efficiency.
Karl Marx’s theory of Exploitation
Karl Marx believed that a capitalist system is inherently exploitative, as the owners of the means of production exploit the labor of the working class. He argued that a command economy would eliminate this exploitation and lead to greater equality and prosperity for all.
John Maynard Keynes Explanation
John Maynard Keynes advocated for a mixed economy, blending free market principles with significant government intervention. He believed that while markets are efficient, they often fail to self-correct, leading to prolonged unemployment and underutilized resources. Keynes argued that governments should implement counter-cyclical policies: increasing spending and reducing taxes during recessions to boost demand, and reducing spending and increasing taxes during booms to prevent inflation. This balanced approach aims to stabilize economic cycles and promote overall economic stability and growth.
Quick Fire Quiz – Knowledge Check
1. Distinguish between who Adam Smith, Friedrich Hayek, and Karl Marx are (10 marks)
2. Explain the difference between a Free Market, Mixed Economy and a Command Economy (10 marks)
3. Explain Adam Smith’s theory of the Invisible Hand (4 marks)
4. Explain Friedrich Hayek’s theory of Spontaneous Order (4 marks)
5. Explain Karl Marx’s theory of Exploitation (4 marks)
Next Revision Topics
- Free, Mixed and Command Economies
- Demand
- Supply
- Government Intervention
- Price Mechanism
- Rational Decision Making
- Absolute & Comparative Advantage
- Inequality & Poverty
- Merit & Demerit Goods
- Externalities
A Level Economics Past Papers
